I quit quitting blogging, for today. I’ll most likely kill the dread pirate thing in the morning, but for now I'd like to puke out two thoughts on the holiday season I've just recovered from.
Soapbox in place. Here we go.
You may have seen this image circulating on facebook.
It stuck in my head, like it might be stuck in yours now, and at some point I wanted to comment on it (something about who is this child and how would it feel to have your kid became the literal poster child for global economic disparity?). I didn’t remember that it said “define necessity”. I thought it said “define need” or something, and couldn’t find it again, or figure out who took the picture, or where. I googled “picture of Christmas presents next to starving African child” or some such thing, and accidentally happened upon one of the most aggressively racist sites I’ve seen in a while. I won’t link you to it since (a) it deserves no further traffic; (b) it will make you want to dig your eyes out of your head with a spoon; and (c) I fear catching some disgusting cyber disease. The site multitasked as a porn hub/place to discuss which cities offer up the youngest whores/general pit of violence, humiliation and denigration.
So, I’m not linking you to it, but trust me when I tell you that there were dozens of comments about those "define necessity" photos and that little boy, somebody’s baby, getting up to clean up the mess the wrapping paper was going to make. About the size of his penis. About one less to spread AIDS. About lazy fuckers waiting for the Red Cross to deliver groceries to their houses. About killing them all.
There were dozens (hundreds? I stopped looking) of other images of African and African-American children, with thousands of different commenters, some anonymous, some pseudononymous, some not, spewing thousands of lines about fucking and/or killing these children. Lines that slithered off the screen and curled themselves around my head like venomous snakes.
I put this out there (a) because, weeks later, I still feel the selfish need to expel the fangs from my brain this way; and (b) for the “post-racial-society” club. You who think that there is a small, isolated, fringe group of Neo-nazis out there perpetuating all the hate. The group discussing the picture above boasts 50,000 + “members” with verified email addresses, (membership not required to comment) and claims to have 22,443,820 hits in a month.
You, mountain/molehill accuser, try clicking on any story prominently featuring a Black person, famous or not, that you come across on the Huffington Post, or any mass media online edition, for that matter. The more tabloidish the better to illustrate my point. Scroll down to the comments. Notice that Anonymous the common commenter is an incredibly prolific, rampant, unabashed racist. Everywhere.
I'm not talking about ignorance or priviledge or bias here. I'm talking straight hate.
Just notice.
Next.
"IF HANUKAH CAN BE CALLED HANUKAH AND KWANZAA CAN BE CALLED KWANZAA, WHY THEN CANT CHRISTMAS BE CALLED CHRISTMAS."
That’s another gem I came across on the holiday facebook circuit.
I read that and thought what the f’ing f are you talking about, f’ing girl I went to high school with? Where do you live now that you can't call Christmas Christmas? She went on to clarify.
IF A MENORAH CAN BE CALLED A MENORAH AND A KINARA BE CALLED A KINARA WHY THEN CAN'T A CHRISTMAS TREE BE CALLED A CHRISTMAS TREE BUT RATHER A HOLIDAY TREE.
Newsflash: this doesn’t even make sense. More important newsflash: You and your tree name are not under attack. You may communicate to all of your friends that you saw the sparkly conifer on the town common by saying “I saw the Christmas tree.” Nobody cares. You can say “Merry Christmas” to every last person you encounter on this earth. You are also free, by the way, to say “Happy Birthday” to anyone, anytime, regardless of their natal anniversary. I’m just trying to give you the heads’ up that it doesn’t always make sense.
Keep the Christ in Xmas. . . The vast majority of you who bitched about keeping the Christ in Christmas were not complaining that your holiest of days has been hijacked to inflate year end retail sales numbers, and consumed by commercialism (a gripe I can understand). The most vocal of you Facebook Christmas Crusaders in my peripheral view worship none above Santa, rail against what you percive to be "political correctness," and refuse to respect or even consider the culture, beliefs, or traditions of the recipient of your canned well wishes. And to me, well, that might make you, by definition, a jackass. If it really bothers you that your work has a “holiday party” or your kid’s school has a “winter concert” instead of a Christmas Pageant, you might want to lighten up. They’re just trying to share the celebration with people who have traditionally felt left out, or worse.
No one is trying to take anything away from you. Your places of employment, banks, schools, courts, post and doctor’s offices, will be open on other people's holidays and closed for your convenience.
But if you want to say “Merry Christmas” to followers of Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Judaism, the Baha’i Faith, and others who may or may not celebrate Christmas, have at it. Yup, you have a right to do so. And you think your free speech is at stake, I get it. Just remember that you also have the right to run around yelling “I am a weasel!” too, but the fact that you don’t, does not, in any way, diminish your right to do so.
Here is what links some of you, in my super-cali-f’ing-fragile head, and on this page, fairly or unfairly, to the Define Necessity dementers/commenters.
a. You seem threatened by the notion of equality. Insecure about your culture’s superiority status. Blowing out Menorahs and Kinaras around you, so your Christmas candle will burn brightest.
b. You lack the insight, empathy, ability, or willingness to imagine how it would feel to be the human being whose existence, feelings, experience, you disregard. Otherwise, I just don’t know how you could do it.
c. I just don’t know how I am ever going to explain you to my kids. Thanks in advance for the broken hearts.




29 comments:
oh my word. i'm exhausted. and now pissed. that picture bugs the heck out of me too, alongside the fb posts starting with "HIV ORPHAN! Sponsor needed" with a pathetic advantageous photo op plastered everywhere. Or the "HIV+ Mother. WOW" trash... I don't even know what to do about it, but bitch. I'm a nonP fundraiser- so I get their theory, but cripes.
Don't get me started on the Christmas rant. I'm a christian and it drives me batty. Freaking crazy people.
Hells yeah. Well said.
Without even seeing the link I am sick.
It's a fucking dazzling PAGAN tree anyhow.
Sincerely,
Reincarnated Druid
You are AMAZING - thank you for spewing all that I feel but am not articulate enough to say. Wow.
amen!
Fantastic post. Loved it!
Whoa. You just took my post-holiday horrid feeling and cranked it up exponentially. I was also plagued by the Keep Christ in Christmas stuff. More than anything, I was so f'ing annoyed by the "It's Merry Christmas, not Happy Holidays" shit. Thank god you didn't link that website, though. why are people so worried about the notion of equality? Seriously, I could throw up. This is brilliantly and angrily written and I totally dig it.
Love you. Love your passion! Still waiting for my card-not kidding. Remind me to tell you why I may have to eat a little crow...UNICEF and their role in HIV treatment.
Bravo! Only you could write this, and I'm glad you did!
Ditto what everyone above said. Welcome back!
Whose the best at representing the collective pissed off-ness of many people. My friend Katy!
yes. that right there.
Like everyone else, I LOVE this!
Never quit blogging again, please! The internet needs you.
Dear Internet,
Katy is Freaking BRILLIANT. I love her so.
She takes my own thoughts out of my own head and writes them on her blog. How does she DO that?
Love,
me
Amen to all that. I wish I could argue something as well as you. I am so glad to know you, Katy.
Hmm..I say keep Christ in Christmas because that is what that holiday is about. I dont push it down people's throats though. I seriously don't like how the holiday is all about santa because all im seeing with kids is what they want, want, want and not what they can give or do for someone else. With that said, i want everyone and anyone to celebrate whatever holiday they choose. I wish that the world appreciated and respected ALL holidays in the way they should be. That image of the tiny child totally freaked me out.
The really hard core Christmas celebrators around here don't even believe in Christmas trees (or, ahem, Holiday trees). I think Christmas trees make them nervous because they're, ahem, phallic.
Anyway- you nailed this. Perfectly. Thanks!
Halle-f'in-lujah. Thank you. I would love to link this to my FB page but won't torture you with the jackass comments that you and I would both get (perhaps even from people we both may have grown up with). Both are things I, too, have noticed and that drive me BONKERS! I actually agonized this year b/c it was the very first year that I sent a card out that said Merry Christmas. I am still annoyed that I let my procrastination/laziness get the better of me. I will not do it again b/c it's been bugging me ever since. Happy New Year and Melkam Genna!
Yes! Like Liz wrote only you could write this. Please, Katy, please, never stop writing. We need you.
Yes, equality. They're scared because our equality means they will have to give up feeling like they are the center of the universe and they are too self centered to be able to handle that.
and yes to hating that poster!!!!! So many ways to comment about gross materialism.
Love you sweet woman.
Thanks.
So glad to have you back. This was another great post. I actually had coffee with a friend of mine this week and we set in her house, surrounded by our American-born and Ethiopian-born toddlers and talked about this post. Thanks for always forcing me to use my brain. Post-holidays it isn't easy...but it is a necessity.
Yep. Fantastic. Love, love, love.
You also illustrated just why I left Facebook and haven't managed have the guts to go back. I take too much to heart, and get so angry. Because heaven forbid that I should comment when someone makes an asinine statement; I got accused of being "led astray" and "helping the devil." I probably help the devil enough without making comments on Facebook, so I just steer clear. When I grow a thicker skin, perhaps...
Amen times 10!
word. up.
We missed you.
Hellz to the yes. That image making the rounds pissed me off like crazy - and many derivations of it too. I'm swimming in pissed off these days - even my family is tired of my critical eyeballs. But damn.
Well, I have to tell you, I love ya girl. Fellow mother of adopted Ethiopian twins out here. (We've exchanged hello's a few times...) you never fail to capture it...lay it down...and say exactly what I am feeling, but can't seem to get down in words. I swear to god, I would love to sit down and have a glass of wine with you. Thank you as always for your incredible words, your insight and your powerful writing. You make a difference. Oh. PS. If you ever end up on the other coast...(Bellingham, WA) bring your twinsies out to play with mine. :) Would love to meet you.
Yup, yup. Agreed. Thanks for having the kahunas to write it all down, swears and all-
I was feeling crappy this christmas, freaked out about money, waiting over a year now for a child, frustrated with life. And then I feel bitchy complaining.
The sad pictures? the awful racists out there? yuck. we can only do what we can do.
However we should print some kind of card with terribly racist web sites on them to give to all the silly people who swear racism is dead and im making a "big deal out of nothing". I cant stand that shit.
Just found your blog via Semi-Feral Mama's blog and I have to say I am in love. Adding you to my blog roll. Oh, and your girls are gorgeous.
Katy, you are, as always, my hero. And that site and those comments?! Wow, beyond sick. I wish on all those sick loser racists just what they deserve.
Post a Comment